The Toronto Blue Jays have been a significant letdown this season. Once expected to be strong contenders in the AL East, they have plummeted to the bottom of the division with a 45-54 record. While this is not as dire as the Chicago White Sox (27-75) or the Oakland Athletics (40-62), the Blue Jays have consistently found ways to lose games, whether through bullpen collapses, inconsistent hitting, or a combination of both.

This disappointing performance has shifted their strategy, and the Blue Jays are now entering ‘seller mode’ as the trade deadline approaches. They have several players on expiring contracts who could yield returns, including Yusei Kikuchi, Justin Turner, Yimi García, Trevor Richards, and Kevin Kiermaier.

Another player who might be considered for trade is Danny Jansen, the Blue Jays’ catcher and the longest-tenured player on the roster since Tim Mayza’s release. Jansen, a key part of the team since his 2018 debut, will enter free agency this winter. In a weak market for catchers, with other names like James McCann, Travis d’Arnaud, Austin Hedges, and Martin Maldonado, Jansen stands out.

Danny Jansen Will Be the Best Available Catcher This Winter

One of the few catchers under 30 hitting free agency, Jansen could easily become the Blue Jays’ most tradeable asset. Known for his defensive skills, particularly his blocking ability, which is in the 98th percentile with a +10 mark this season, Jansen has also built a strong rapport with the Jays’ starting pitchers, most of whom were acquired through offseason signings rather than internal development.

These factors will likely draw trade interest for Jansen, but there are compelling reasons to consider keeping him for the long term.

Extend or Trade?

Firstly, Jansen is a fan favorite among a Blue Jays fanbase that currently has little to cheer for. He is also a valuable presence in the locker room, contributing to a clubhouse culture that the organization values highly. This emphasis on team chemistry was a key reason behind Charlie Montoyo’s firing in 2022 when he lost the clubhouse.

Offensively, Jansen can be a significant contributor when he’s in form, with a smooth swing that generates power. He has hit double-digit home runs each year since 2019 (excluding the COVID-shortened season) and has a career .734 OPS. This season, he has an impressive chase rate value in the 94th percentile and has drawn 24 walks.

Defensively, Jansen has a solid track record, earning the trust of the pitching staff with his leadership and blocking ability. He has a .993 fielding percentage and has allowed only three passed balls since 2021. At 29, he has become the Jays’ primary catcher over Alejandro Kirk and has gained the support of the starting pitchers.